Ruby S.-J. works with glass and she works with fire. She is a neon sign technician and she understands the vacuum. She bends the glass tubes and she welds the electrodes to the ends. She connects the tube to a pump and she pulls the air out of the glass.
✦
If the seal is good the vacuum holds and the neon glows red when the current hits the gas.
She told me that a leak is a failure of the joint and it does not matter if the glass is strong or if the gas is pure. I read the terms and conditions of my own service contracts today and I thought about Ruby and her vacuum. The terms are long and they are dry but they describe the joints of a life. The electrodes are the points of contact and the glass is the structure but the joint is where the failure lives.
The Simulation of the Gap
Nélia sits at a long table in a room with white walls. She is not a glass technician but she manages a referral desk for a clinic in Rio de Janeiro. She participated in a tabletop exercise yesterday and she had two piles of paper in front of her. One pile was the outgoing referrals and one pile was the incoming files.
She moved a sample referral from the outgoing pile to the center of the table. The simulation clock moved forward and the office closed for the weekend. The receiving pile did not exist yet because the other office had not opened the file.
Nélia looked at the paper in the middle of the table and she saw that both offices marked the task as handled. The sender had sent the file and the receiver had not yet been tasked to open it.
The Digital Contradiction
I believe in the efficiency of the modern office but I see the paper in the dirt and I know it is a ghost. It is a contradiction of the digital age. We have faster tools and we have more data but we have the same gaps. I read the policy on patient continuity and I followed every step but the gap remained.
The neon gas escapes because the joint is not sealed. The electrons hit the atoms and the energy becomes light. It is a physical certainty and it is beautiful but it requires a perfect seal. If the air gets in the light goes out. The air is the silence between two desks.
1.
The Desk Where “Complete” Means “Gone”
In the simulation Nélia marked the referral as sent. Her system showed a green check mark. The check mark means the data left the server and it means the task is off her dashboard. She is a good worker and she wants a clean dashboard.
But the receiving office has a different system and their dashboard does not show the file until a clerk clicks a button. The patient is no longer in the first system and the patient is not yet in the second system. The patient exists in the wire and the wire does not have a manager.
This is the first crack. It is a failure of the definition of the word complete. We say a thing is done when we have pushed it away but the thing is only done when it has been caught.
2.
The Hour Between Two Different Clocks
A clinic in closes at six in the evening and a scheduling center in stays open until eight. A patient calls at seven and the center takes the information. They send the referral to the clinic. The clinic is dark and the staff is at home.
Pos. 89 / 142
The Monday backlog: Your “Friday 7 PM” urgency is just message #89 in a 142-file pile.
The referral sits in a queue. On Monday morning the clinic has 142 new messages and the referral is number 89. The patient thinks the process started at seven on Friday but the process does not start until ten on Monday.
The three days of silence are a vacuum and the vacuum pulls at the patient’s trust. I once sent a message to a technician and I thought he ignored me but he was simply in a different time zone and his clock was not my clock.
3.
The Silence of the Successful Handoff
The most dangerous moment is the moment of success. The referral is sent and it is received and the appointment is booked. The desks are happy and they move to the next file.
But the patient has a question about the test and they call the first clinic. The first clinic says they no longer have the file. The patient calls the second clinic and the second clinic says they do not have the clinical history yet.
The handoff was successful in the database but it was a failure in the conversation. The desks are reliable in isolation and they perform their duties but they do not own the space between the clinics. It is like the neon tube that has a perfect vacuum but the transformer is too far away to jump the gap.
4.
The Policy That Only Sees the Half-Moon
I read 42 pages of healthcare regulations last night and I found that they focus on the clinic and they focus on the hospital. They do not focus on the sidewalk. There are rules for how to store a record and there are rules for how to bill a consultation.
There are no rules for who calls the patient when the fax machine runs out of paper. The policy sees the half-moon of the sender and it sees the half-moon of the receiver. It does not see the full circle of the care.
In the tabletop exercise Nélia tried to reopen a file that she had already sent. The system would not let her. It said the file was locked because it belonged to another department. She wanted to help the patient but the software was a wall and she could not climb it.
5.
The Invisible Inventory of the Waiting Room
A patient needs to marcar tratamento de alergia and they have the paperwork from a primary doctor. They arrive at the specialist office and they find that the blood test results did not follow the referral.
The specialist cannot see the patient without the results. The primary doctor says the results were attached to the email. The specialist says the email only had one attachment and it was the insurance card. This is the invisible inventory.
It is the data that we assume is there but we do not verify. Projeto Brasil Sem Alergia has served over 703,212 people and they know that the details of the test are as important as the date of the visit.
If the spirometry results are missing the allergist is blind. The system must account for the physical presence of the data and not just the existence of the file.
6.
The Boundary Where Data Becomes Noise
We have too much information and it becomes a sound that we cannot hear. A referral comes in with 58 pages of notes. The receiving clerk looks for the diagnosis and the diagnosis is on page 31. The clerk misses it and they ask the patient to repeat the history.
The patient becomes frustrated and they stop answering questions. The data was there but the data was noise. I saw a neon sign once that flickered because the wire was touching the metal frame. The current was leaking into the ground.
The sign was bright but it was unstable. The referral is a wire and it must be insulated from the noise of the system. We must send only what is needed and we must ensure it is seen.
7.
The Recovery That No One Owns
This is the core of the problem. If a referral fails at the joint no one is assigned to fix it. The sender thinks the receiver has it and the receiver does not know it exists. The patient is the only one who knows the light is out.
Nélia discovered this in her simulation. She tried to find a protocol for a lost referral and she found nothing. The manual had a chapter on sending and a chapter on receiving but it had no chapter on losing.
We must test the boundary conditions because that is where the patients fall.
The Quality of the Joint
The quality of a network is not the speed of the clinics in or the size of the clinics in . It is the strength of the joints. Ruby S.-J. finished her sign and she turned it on.
The glass glowed a steady orange and the light filled the shop. She watched it for to make sure the vacuum held. She did not just build the tubes and she did not just fill the gas. She verified the joint.
We must do the same with our referrals and our bookings. We must look at the gap between the desks and we must ensure the vacuum is perfect and the light is constant.
“The handoff is a gift that is dropped in the dirt because the hands are only trained to let go.”