The metal of the chair felt cold against the back of his legs and the air in the room smelled of floor wax. Faiz sat at the long table and he waited for the senior analyst to finish her tea. The cup was white and the steam rose in a straight line and then it broke. He held a new notebook in his hands and the paper was white and the edges were sharp.
He had been in the office for and he had been told many things about the firm. He had been told about the lunch hours and the parking rules and the history of the bank. Now he was waiting to hear about the work.
The Weight of the Locked Door
The senior analyst was a woman and her name was Sarah. She set the tea cup down and the sound was sharp against the wood of the table. She said that the firm had all the resources a man could want and she said that the information was there for the taking.
She spoke about the research papers and the industry reports and the Arabic journals. She said that they had a membership to ifikr.my and that everything was available. Faiz wrote the name in his notebook and he felt a sense of relief. He thought that the door was open and he thought that the path was clear. He closed his notebook and he went to his desk.
The Distance Between Resource and Access
The desk was small and the surface was grey. He sat down and he looked for the link but he did not find it. He looked for the password in his orientation folder but the folder was full of tax forms and insurance papers. He saw Sarah across the room and she was busy with a phone call.
He did not want to disturb her but he could not start his work. He felt a small knot in his stomach and the knot was made of a strange kind of shame. He had been told the source was available and now he felt like a child who could not find his shoes.
He waited for and then he walked to her desk. He asked her for the login and she looked up from her screen and her eyes were tired. She said that the login was saved on her computer and she said she would send him a link.
He went back to his desk and he waited. The link arrived in an email but the link took him to a page that asked for a name and a secret word. He did not have the word. He walked back to her desk and she was gone to a meeting.
He sat at his desk and he cleaned the screen of his phone with a small cloth. The glass was cold and smooth and he rubbed it until the smudges were gone. He felt the weight of the afternoon and the weight was heavy.
This is the way that teams break. A leader says that a thing is available and the leader believes this is true. The leader has the key in her pocket and she has forgotten that the door is locked for everyone else. She thinks the team is slow or she thinks the team is needy but the team is just standing in front of a locked door.
The Lesson of the Lighthouse
When we talk about what we can read we should talk about who has the key. We should not say that the library is open when only one person has the key to the front gate.
“He told me once that a light is a useless thing if the glass is dirty and he said that a light is a useless thing if the man on the sea cannot see the beam.”
– James S., Lighthouse Keeper
James spends his days cleaning the glass and he spends his days checking the fuel. He knows that the light belongs to the ships but the light is his responsibility. He does not say that the light is available and then go to sleep. He stays awake and he makes sure the path is clear. He told me that most people build a light and then they walk away and they think the job is done.
The Efficiency Drain
A large study showed that 40% of research firm employees lose a full day of work every week just chasing documents.
I think about the lighthouse when I think about the data in an office. We build a repository and we fill it with fatwas and Shariah regulations and we think that the job is finished. We put the reports from RHB Islamic and MBSB Bank in a folder and we think that the team is now wise.
But a folder is a wall if you do not have the password. A repository is a hole in the ground if you do not have the map. We spend our time collecting the gold and we spend no time making the keys.
That is the same as throwing money into a fire. It is a human cost and it is a cost of spirit. A man wants to do his work and he wants to be useful. He does not want to ask for a password three times in one afternoon. He does not want to feel like a beggar at the table of his own company.
Beyond the List: Access as a Social Contract
When Sarah tells Faiz that the I-FIKR is available she is making a promise. She is saying that he has the same power that she has. But she has the password and he does not. She has the history of the research and he does not. The power is not equal and the promise is a lie.
She does not mean to lie but she has forgotten what it is like to be on the outside of the door. She has been inside for so long that she thinks the door is a ghost.
The Leader’s View
“I have told my assistants the files are in the cloud. I go to dinner and feel good about my leadership while eating steak.”
The Reality
“They asked for access at . They were sitting in the dark, unable to work because I had the key.”
I have made this mistake many times. I was the ghost in the machine and I was the one who stopped the work. We must change the way we talk about our tools. We should not list our memberships in a dossier and we should not brag about our journals.
We should look at the list and we should ask how many people can open the first page. We should ask how many steps it takes to get to the fatwa. If the steps are more than three then the resource is not available. It is just a thing that we own.
There is a great difference between owning a thing and using a thing. A bank can own a thousand books but if the books are in a vault then the bank is still ignorant. The analyst needs more than a reading list and he needs more than a pat on the back.
Breaking the Cycle of Guarded Knowledge
He needs a system that does not require him to be a pest. He needs a corporate membership that is built for a team and not for a single ghost in an office. He needs to know that when he is told to find a Shariah resolution from AEON Bank it will not take him three hours of asking for a link. He needs to feel that his time is valued and he needs to feel that his work is the priority.
When we build a repository we are building a foundation. The foundation must be solid and it must be accessible to the builders. If the builders cannot reach the stone then the house will never rise. We focus on the collection and we focus on the journals and the research and the scholars.
These are good things and they are necessary things. But the most necessary thing is the hand that reaches for the page. If the hand is blocked then the scholarship is a dead thing. It sits in the dark and it gathers dust and it helps no one.
I looked at my phone again and the screen was still clean but there were no new messages. I thought about Faiz and I thought about the cold metal of his chair. He is a young man and he has much to offer but he is learning a bad lesson.
He is learning that the information is a secret. He is learning that he must beg for the tools of his trade. This is a lesson that will stay with him and it will make him a guarded man. He will grow up to be a senior analyst and he will keep his passwords to himself. He will do this because that is what was done to him.
We can break the cycle and we can do it with a simple change of mind. We can decide that access is the first part of the work and not the last part. We can decide that we will not mention a resource until we have handed over the key.